Toyota’s Marketing Mistakes Cost Them Their Brand Equity

Share on TwitterSubmit to StumbleUpon

Let me start by saying it’s very, very easy to sit on the sidelines and critique Toyota for their bungling of their accelerator and brake problems. I’m sure they’re working around the clock to solve the problem, both from a technical point-of-view and a branding/PR point-of-view. But they seem to be stumbling badly on the branding/PR side of the equation.

So far, in all the news reports I’ve seen, I’ve never seen anyone from corporate headquarters who directly addressed the problem with a news anchor or other journalist. Zero. Zip. Nada. (I’m not saying they haven’t had someone from headquarters on the news, I’m saying that I haven’t seen a face-to-face interview with someone from corporate — and I’m a 24-hour-a-day news junkie. Not good.)

The one gentleman I did see was a Toyota dealer from outside of Boston who did his best to answer questions on CNN. But someone who is untrained in PR crisis management shouldn’t be on national TV trying to put out the fire.

Here are several lessons that can be learned from Toyota’s mishandling of the situation:

  1. Get out ahead of the story: If you wait until the news networks are reporting on the story around the clock, you’re too late. Get out ahead of the story — address issues before they make headlines so you’re being proactive instead of reactive.
  2. Put a face on the corporation: Don’t hide behind press releases and statements from headquarters. Get a well-trained, well-spoken representative to address the issues.
  3. Put your crisis management team into action: My friends in PR tell me that the most valuable (and expensive) team members in their arsenal are the crisis management people. Why? Because they’re good. And they’re worth every penny.
  4. Practice as much transparency as possible: I know it’s hard to be 100% transparent when you don’t even know the full extent of the problem, but if you come across as stonewalling, you’re in trouble. If you don’t know the answer, tell people that. And then get started trying to find the answer.
  5. Turn on your social media after-burners: If I were Toyota, I’d have 150 to 250 people working around the clock visiting blogs, forums, chat rooms, YouTube channels and other venues with explanations on how to deal with the problem. Identify yourself and let people know you’re from corporate. Then give them the information that they’re looking for. It’s a new world and it’s time to jump into the fray.

Those are just a few ideas off the top of my head. What are some other ideas? What would you do if you were in Toyota’s shoes? Do you agree with what I’ve written above?

Print Friendly
  • G.C.

    I agree. But I would do something different and fresh for Toyota and in the marketing world itself. Marketing “experts” are formulaic and industry-driven. By their own industry, the marketing world. Not by consumers. That's an old-school stale approach.
    21st century consumers are different. Word of mouth is actually far more important than it ever has been due to the degree of social networking. Consumers like 'catchy', imagery, graphics, youth (yes, even the oldsters), coolness. And personality.
    Toyota should get personal. They should get a young face – not an actor, not a professional PR spokesperson. An athlete. Or something like that. Someone they promote through their product and image. And not a big-name household athlete, like Shaun White. Someone modest and humble, just on the edge of being a household name, but not. A hardworking, working-class background, ethnically diverse.
    Consumers like that. First, they watch because it catches interest. Then they see it again or a different version with the same person and they start to own it. Then they get invested – who is that? The campaign answers that for them. Then they feel committed and remember it. Everybody, not just people who like Toyotas. Frankly, Toyota owners are not the ones watching the ads.

  • jamieturner

    Great comment, G.C. Thanks for sharing your ideas. You've got some interesting thoughts here. If you'd ever like to do a guest post with some of your expanded ideas, feel free to visit 60SecondMarketer.com/SubmitContent. You'll find our writer's guidelines there.

    Best,
    Jamie

  • http://www.60SecondMarketer.com Jamie Turner

    Great comment, G.C. Thanks for sharing your ideas. You’ve got some interesting thoughts here. If you’d ever like to do a guest post with some of your expanded ideas, feel free to visit 60SecondMarketer.com/SubmitContent. You’ll find our writer’s guidelines there. nnBest,nJamie

  • http://www.justmobilephone.com/snowbreeze-4-2-8-jailbreak-ios-sn0wbreeze-2-7/ snowbreeze 4.2.8

    21st century consumers are different. Word of mouth is actually far more important than it ever has been due to the degree of social networking. Consumers like ‘catchy’, imagery, graphics, youth (yes, even the oldsters), coolness. And personality.

  • http://www.trirachmat.com/trade4target-indias-top-99-accuracy-tips.html Trade4Target

    I really appreciate your post and you explain each and every point very well.Thanks for sharing this information.And I’ll love to read your next post too.
    Regards:
    Trade4Target


The 60 Second Marketer is a free online magazine brought to you by BKV Interactive and Direct Response. We try to provide quick updates on the newest tools, tips and techniques in marketing. We also try to accomplish that with a dose of humor or levity. As it turns out, we're pretty good at providing tools, tips and techniques, but we're not actually all that funny. Which would explain why people don't call us "funny" as much as they call us "laughable." Bummer. Our offices, for those of you who are interested, are located in Atlanta (404-233-0332) and Kansas City (913-648-8333). We also have offices on Bora Bora, but they don't have the phones installed yet.

© 60 Second Marketer, a division of BKV, Inc.